How much time do you have?
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen">
1/ https://twitter.com/SailorBrendan/status/1265983424189222915">https://twitter.com/SailorBre...
1/ https://twitter.com/SailorBrendan/status/1265983424189222915">https://twitter.com/SailorBre...
I& #39;m not a historian or political science guru – I tag in Prof. @KevinMKruse for those things – but my assumption is that ethnonationalists / neo-Nazis / etc join police because of the unchecked power police have these days to terrorize minorities
2/
@SailorBrendan
2/
@SailorBrendan
So reduce that power – and hold police accountable for abusing it – and you reduce the allure to those folks pretty quick
And on that front, the to-do list is quite long
3/
@SailorBrendan
And on that front, the to-do list is quite long
3/
@SailorBrendan
QI is a doctrine created from scratch by judges. It was never enacted into law by a legislature or signed by an executive; judges created it on their own
And it protects police from being held accountable for their bad judgment
4/
@SailorBrendan
Qualified immunity means a policeman cannot be sued civilly for violating your rights – killing you, brutalizing you, etc – unless that right was "clearly established" at the time of the violation
What does "clearly established" mean? Whatever a judge wants
5/
@SailorBrendan
What does "clearly established" mean? Whatever a judge wants
5/
@SailorBrendan
For example, police in California were sued b/c they stole $100K+ in rare coins while executing a search warrant
They received QI – the case was dismissed – because "stealing during a search" was not "clearly established" as illegal
6/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1108477962599522305">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
They received QI – the case was dismissed – because "stealing during a search" was not "clearly established" as illegal
6/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1108477962599522305">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
In practice, almost nothing at all is ever "clearly established"
If a police officer chokes someone to death for sport, you& #39;d say "killing for sport is illegal!"
Then a judge& #39;d say "just killing them with his shin, not with his knee"
7/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1107298113964904448">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
If a police officer chokes someone to death for sport, you& #39;d say "killing for sport is illegal!"
Then a judge& #39;d say "just killing them with his shin, not with his knee"
7/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1107298113964904448">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
And because qualified immunity is what& #39;s called an immunity "from suit," it means those cases get dismissed early and never make it to discovery or trial
Meaning facts almost never come out to define what will be "clearly established" in the future
8/
@SailorBrendan
Meaning facts almost never come out to define what will be "clearly established" in the future
8/
@SailorBrendan
Reuters had an exceptionally thorough deep dive on qualified immunity just a couple weeks ago
Read this when your time permits; it& #39;s very long, but highlights how pernicious the doctrine is
9/
@SailorBrendan https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-police-immunity-scotus/">https://www.reuters.com/investiga...
Read this when your time permits; it& #39;s very long, but highlights how pernicious the doctrine is
9/
@SailorBrendan https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-police-immunity-scotus/">https://www.reuters.com/investiga...
[Probably should have mentioned it earlier in the thread, but the vast majority of what you& #39;re going to see on this list requires legislative action at some level and a willing executive to implement it. So none of this will happen soon without voting.]
10/
@SailorBrendan
10/
@SailorBrendan
We require it for doctors, pharmacists, and other professions where you could be killed by incompetence or malice. Police should be know different
11/
@SailorBrendan
Requiring police to carry insurance serves two goals at the same time:
(A) it protects taxpayers from having to shell out $$$$$$$$ in settlement money
and
(B) insurance rates for individual officers will rise based on how bad they are
12/
@SailorBrendan
(A) it protects taxpayers from having to shell out $$$$$$$$ in settlement money
and
(B) insurance rates for individual officers will rise based on how bad they are
12/
@SailorBrendan
If you& #39;re like the mongrel-with-a-badge who murdered #GeorgeFloyd – with several prior brutality incidents on your record – the cost for a city to insure you eventually hits a point where you& #39;re not worth the expense, and become unemployable as a cop
13/
@SailorBrendan
13/
@SailorBrendan
Malpractice insurance for police is a topic that @ConLawWarrior has written about often
14/
@SailorBrendan https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/make-cops-carry-liability-insurance-private-sector-knows-how-spread-risks">https://www.cato.org/publicati...
14/
@SailorBrendan https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/make-cops-carry-liability-insurance-private-sector-knows-how-spread-risks">https://www.cato.org/publicati...
Did you know most states only require cops to have a high school diploma? And the police academy is typically only 6-8 weeks long?
You end up with a lot of young bad cops who become old bad cops
15/
@SailorBrendan
Police should have at least a 4-year college degree. Not b/c those degrees are particularly relevant to the job, but b/c the life experience from being in college for that timespan – being around people who aren& #39;t like you, navigating conflict, etc – matters
16/
@SailorBrendan
16/
@SailorBrendan
But if a state won& #39;t require that baseline legislatively, departments can accomplish the same goal by offering a pay bump (similar to what many localities do for teachers with advanced degrees)
17/
@SailorBrendan
17/
@SailorBrendan
Same concept as pay bumps for degrees, but in this case offered to police who actually live in the neighborhoods they patrol
18/
@SailorBrendan
Police officers are less likely to escalate and kill people when it& #39;s their neighbors that they& #39;re dealing with
19/
@SailorBrendan
19/
@SailorBrendan
Every District Attorney& #39;s Office in the country knows which cops on which police forces are documented liars who can& #39;t be trusted to provide sworn testimony in court
They end up on what are dubbed "Brady lists"
20/
@SailorBrendan
The name is a reference to the Brady v Maryland case by the Supreme Court, which ruled the Government has to turn over all evidence that tends to exonerate someone accused of a crime
Here, though, it& #39;s a misnomer: most Brady lists aren& #39;t disclosed at all
21/
@SailorBrendan
Here, though, it& #39;s a misnomer: most Brady lists aren& #39;t disclosed at all
21/
@SailorBrendan
They& #39;re not given to defense attorneys, and they& #39;re never ever ever ever (ever) given to the public
When California recently enacted new laws to make this info known, police unions went apesh*t and sued to block the laws from taking effect
22/
@SailorBrendan
When California recently enacted new laws to make this info known, police unions went apesh*t and sued to block the laws from taking effect
22/
@SailorBrendan
I& #39;d argue *all* records of police misconduct should be publicly accessible. But if that& #39;s a bridge too far, at the very list it should include officers who are too dishonest to be trusted in court
23/
@SailorBrendan
23/
@SailorBrendan
Your head would spin at some of the sh*t police get away with because it& #39;s *written into their contracts that they can*
@deray, @samswey, @ClintSmithIII, and several others have written about this often
24/
@SailorBrendan
The ability to hop / skip / jump from department to department as officers are fired
Elaborate termination procedures that block their firing in the first place, or enable them to easily get reinstated with back pay
The list goes on
25/
@SailorBrendan
Elaborate termination procedures that block their firing in the first place, or enable them to easily get reinstated with back pay
The list goes on
25/
@SailorBrendan
For further reading on this, check out http://checkthepolice.org"> http://checkthepolice.org
26/
@SailorBrendan
26/
@SailorBrendan
Police these days operate like paramilitary units, complete with military gear and recruitment videos that promote a "domestic warfare" mindset
27/
@SailorBrendan
Except the military has rules of engagement, a Uniform Code of Military Justice, and courts martial that will punish you severely for misconduct
Police have qualified immunity, a "Blue Lives Matter" PR apparatus, and oodles of case law to protect them
28/
@SailorBrendan
Police have qualified immunity, a "Blue Lives Matter" PR apparatus, and oodles of case law to protect them
28/
@SailorBrendan
Cities and states can modify guidelines on when and how police can use force, and when they can escalate
That needs to be flipped on its head, to promote de-escalation and the preservation of life as the overriding concern
29/
@SailorBrendan
That needs to be flipped on its head, to promote de-escalation and the preservation of life as the overriding concern
29/
@SailorBrendan
On this one, check out http://useofforceproject.org"> http://useofforceproject.org
30/
@SailorBrendan
30/
@SailorBrendan
A large number of police brutality incidents – and the corresponding court cases that have eroded Fourth Amendment rights – come from traffic stops
31/
@SailorBrendan
Those traffic stops end up disproportionately targeting racial minorities
See, e.g., this Stanford study that analyzed 95,000,000+ traffic stops across 56 departments over 7 years, documenting what& #39;s known as the "veil of darkness"
32/
@SailorBrendan https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2020-05/ssoe-psf050620.php">https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_relea...
See, e.g., this Stanford study that analyzed 95,000,000+ traffic stops across 56 departments over 7 years, documenting what& #39;s known as the "veil of darkness"
32/
@SailorBrendan https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2020-05/ssoe-psf050620.php">https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_relea...
You can see similar results in the states contained in the http://OpenDataPolicing.com"> http://OpenDataPolicing.com website (covering a combined 49,000,000 traffic stops across 3 states)
33/
@SailorBrendan
https://opendatapolicing.com"> https://opendatapolicing.com
33/
@SailorBrendan
https://opendatapolicing.com"> https://opendatapolicing.com
Nearly all of those stops don& #39;t actually have to happen. They& #39;re done to provide a basis for fishing expeditions by the Government, and to raise money via citations
Nothing at all to do with public safety
34/
@SailorBrendan
Nothing at all to do with public safety
34/
@SailorBrendan
Reduce the incidence of police interaction with citizens and you reduce the number of opportunities bad police have to kill someone
35/
@SailorBrendan
35/
@SailorBrendan
I quite literally can& #39;t count how many times I& #39;ve tweeted about police officers caught on camera planting evidence
36/
@SailorBrendan
For most departments, most of the time, the responding officer becomes the arresting officer who then testifies in court about the crime
This incentivizes lying: planting evidence, making sh*t up on police reports, lying under oath in court
All to "win"
37/
@SailorBrendan
This incentivizes lying: planting evidence, making sh*t up on police reports, lying under oath in court
All to "win"
37/
@SailorBrendan
The bona fide first responders to a scene – often to situations where emotions run high – shouldn& #39;t be the ones quarterbacking evidence collection too
38/
@SailorBrendan
38/
@SailorBrendan
So-called "line" prosecutors – the ones in the courtrooms every day trying cases – come to rely on the police they work with regularly
So they& #39;ll almost never prosecute them for wrongdoing
39/
@SailorBrendan
If there& #39;s ever an incident of alleged police misconduct – everything from a beating to a murder – a special prosecutor from outside that jurisdiction should be assigned to review it and decide if charges are warranted
40/
@SailorBrendan
40/
@SailorBrendan
Tying in with #10, most states think police are infallible and will never prosecute – or they& #39;ll do a deliberately sh*t job so the officer is found not guilty
The Feds need to be more willing to prosecute in those cases
41/
@SailorBrendan
Federal prosecutions for criminal violations of civil rights laws were instrumental in helping curtail killings during the Civil Rights Era
We& #39;ve got the same sort of killings happening now, it& #39;s just Government employees doing it
42/
@SailorBrendan
We& #39;ve got the same sort of killings happening now, it& #39;s just Government employees doing it
42/
@SailorBrendan
Remember that traffic stop a few tweets up? Most states have developed uniform traffic reports to systematize data collection
Do it elsewhere
43/
@SailorBrendan
Unless something& #39;s been developed in the past couple years and I& #39;ve missed it, there is no uniform standard of what data to collect for non-traffic police activity – including incidents where force is used
There is also no req for that info to be reported
44/
@SailorBrendan
There is also no req for that info to be reported
44/
@SailorBrendan
The Obama admin took some baby steps down that road with their Police Data Initiative, and several other orgs are trying similar things, but there& #39;s nothing universal yet
Like COVID testing, you can& #39;t tell how bad something is if you can& #39;t measure it
45/
@SailorBrendan
Like COVID testing, you can& #39;t tell how bad something is if you can& #39;t measure it
45/
@SailorBrendan
The protections provided by the "criminal justice" amendments to the Constitution have been blown all to hell after centuries of court decisions
46/
@SailorBrendan
For example, at the federal level the Supreme Court has ruled it& #39;s totally 100% fine for the police to violate your Fourth Amendment rights as long as they do so "in good faith"
I& #39;ve talked a bit about that before in this old thread
47/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/821037969356324864">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
I& #39;ve talked a bit about that before in this old thread
47/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/821037969356324864">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
A lot of states, run by legislators of both parties who are embarrassingly sycophantic police apologists, then enacted the Herring test into law
It& #39;d be nice to see it abolished instead
48/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/821041887658307586">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
It& #39;d be nice to see it abolished instead
48/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/821041887658307586">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
(You& #39;ll notice the vote on gutting the Exclusionary Rule was quite lopsided. That& #39;s because the love of police brutality is strongly bipartisan.)
49/
@SailorBrendan
49/
@SailorBrendan
The same concept applies to all the other rights that the Supreme Court has scaled back over the years
They& #39;re constitutional *minimums* that state legislatures can expand upon at will
50/
@SailorBrendan
They& #39;re constitutional *minimums* that state legislatures can expand upon at will
50/
@SailorBrendan
You often hear someone has been arrested for "resisting arrest" – but did you know you can be arrested for resisting *even when there was no basis for an arrest* in the first place?
51/
@SailorBrendan
In North Carolina, our statute is called "resist / delay / obstruct a peace officer," also known by its acronym RDO or colloquially as "contempt of cop"
It& #39;s a basis to arrest if you ask questions, move too slowly, or just piss off a cop for any reason at all
52/
@SailorBrendan
It& #39;s a basis to arrest if you ask questions, move too slowly, or just piss off a cop for any reason at all
52/
@SailorBrendan
You will undoubtedly be shocked to learn that it& #39;s almost exclusively a "black" crime, used by police whenever they want to pretend you& #39;re being "uppity" and don& #39;t know your place in our racial caste system
53/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/798336260108496896">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
53/
@SailorBrendan https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/798336260108496896">https://twitter.com/greg_douc...
These statutes need to be trimmed, and abusing them should be a separate basis for professional discipline
54/
@SailorBrendan
54/
@SailorBrendan
(We& #39;ve reached the point in the thread where I& #39;m remembering stuff I should have mentioned earlier
Crimes by police should have sentences comparable to the analogous crime by a civilian, *at least*
55/
@SailorBrendan
If you kill someone, the sentence you& #39;re going to get will end up vastly longer than a police officer convicted of the same crime
So even if you ge through alllllllll of the prosecutorial hurdles mentioned upthread, police get less prison time to boot
56/
@SailorBrendan
So even if you ge through alllllllll of the prosecutorial hurdles mentioned upthread, police get less prison time to boot
56/
@SailorBrendan
Same if you steal money, or steal property, or embezzle
The punishment for you doing it will always be far more harsh than a cop convicted of doing the same thing
57/
@SailorBrendan
The punishment for you doing it will always be far more harsh than a cop convicted of doing the same thing
57/
@SailorBrendan
I& #39;d argue the sentences for crimes by police – and crimes by all public servants tbh – should actually be *more* harsh. Because they& #39;re violating public trust in addition to the law
But we can start by at least making the sentences comparable
58/
@SailorBrendan
But we can start by at least making the sentences comparable
58/
@SailorBrendan
I& #39;m sure there& #39;s plenty more that I& #39;m forgetting at the moment
Back in 2016, I ran for the state legislature and had quite a bit of court reform stuff on my platform. I left the website up here
59/
@SailorBrendan
https://VoteTGreg.com/issue/court-reform">https://VoteTGreg.com/issue/cou...
Back in 2016, I ran for the state legislature and had quite a bit of court reform stuff on my platform. I left the website up here
59/
@SailorBrendan
https://VoteTGreg.com/issue/court-reform">https://VoteTGreg.com/issue/cou...
None of these, by itself, is going to fix everything
But implementing several of them starts to change the incentive structure in place around policing. And that will start steering things toward more-desirable policy outcomes
60/
@SailorBrendan
But implementing several of them starts to change the incentive structure in place around policing. And that will start steering things toward more-desirable policy outcomes
60/
@SailorBrendan
Happy to answer any questions you& #39;ve got, and apologies for carpet-bombing your @& #39;s
61/61
@SailorBrendan
61/61
@SailorBrendan
Also just realized my @& #39;s are a shambles now too
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen">
Exactly. Literally nothing at all stopping them from punching in your plate and the DMV spitting out a letter to your last known address saying "your plate light is out, fix it in 30 days or we& #39;ll suspend your license" https://twitter.com/airned36/status/1266081400953995265">https://twitter.com/airned36/...
All true
But pressure needs to be put on current elected officials too, esp when sheriffs / district attorneys / etc often aren& #39;t elected until "off-year" elections
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😕" title="Verwirrtes Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Verwirrtes Gesicht"> https://twitter.com/questauthority/status/1266058639137280001">https://twitter.com/questauth...
But pressure needs to be put on current elected officials too, esp when sheriffs / district attorneys / etc often aren& #39;t elected until "off-year" elections
Police licensing is what we have now. It doesn& #39;t work
If we want to set a minimum hiring age of 24 for those who don& #39;t have a college degree, I& #39;m fine with that too https://twitter.com/massena1/status/1266070498678640650">https://twitter.com/massena1/...
If we want to set a minimum hiring age of 24 for those who don& #39;t have a college degree, I& #39;m fine with that too https://twitter.com/massena1/status/1266070498678640650">https://twitter.com/massena1/...
Possibly, but I& #39;m skeptical. The number of new law enforcement openings in any given year is far smaller than the total pool of potential applicants from disadvantaged backgrounds who got a college degree https://twitter.com/thedstecks/status/1266072321971965952">https://twitter.com/thedsteck...
Scroll up to #2
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😉" title="Zwinkerndes Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Zwinkerndes Gesicht"> https://twitter.com/no_scooters/status/1266087167232741376">https://twitter.com/no_scoote...
It exists, called CALEA (the Commission on Accreditation of Law Enforcement Agencies)
But it& #39;s a bit like college accreditation, in that its ability to enforce change is both limited and very slow https://twitter.com/ladiesbane/status/1266088349275549696">https://twitter.com/ladiesban...
But it& #39;s a bit like college accreditation, in that its ability to enforce change is both limited and very slow https://twitter.com/ladiesbane/status/1266088349275549696">https://twitter.com/ladiesban...
No doubt, because for a lot of departments the pay sucks
Durham routinely loses people to spots like Cary, which pay better and require less work
That& #39;s why the extra $$$$$$$ is needed to incentivize the applicant pool you want https://twitter.com/bikemrown/status/1266088304254029824">https://twitter.com/bikemrown...
Durham routinely loses people to spots like Cary, which pay better and require less work
That& #39;s why the extra $$$$$$$ is needed to incentivize the applicant pool you want https://twitter.com/bikemrown/status/1266088304254029824">https://twitter.com/bikemrown...
My Twitter app is borked, I& #39;m not seeing most responses to most of the thread
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😑" title="Ausdrucksloses Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Ausdrucksloses Gesicht">
May take some time for it to unf*ck itself so I can respond, sorry y& #39;all
May take some time for it to unf*ck itself so I can respond, sorry y& #39;all
I& #39;m fine with it
There are a *lot* of in-courtroom changes to be made as well, I just didn& #39;t get into them b/c that doesn& #39;t come up if an officer& #39;s killed someone first https://twitter.com/spacemaned/status/1266089955413168129">https://twitter.com/spacemane...
There are a *lot* of in-courtroom changes to be made as well, I just didn& #39;t get into them b/c that doesn& #39;t come up if an officer& #39;s killed someone first https://twitter.com/spacemaned/status/1266089955413168129">https://twitter.com/spacemane...
How many drivers are there on the roads? And yet most (every?) state requires liability insurance to have a license
It doesn& #39;t need to be easy to be doable https://twitter.com/nick_hentoff/status/1266082403908550658">https://twitter.com/nick_hent...
It doesn& #39;t need to be easy to be doable https://twitter.com/nick_hentoff/status/1266082403908550658">https://twitter.com/nick_hent...
My off-the-cuff guess is no, because in this scenario it would fall under the government speech side of things
Just like the government can require uniforms of its employees, it could require suits when in court
Trickier question for off-duty cops
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🤔" title="Denkendes Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Denkendes Gesicht"> https://twitter.com/augustbenassi/status/1266100667334066176">https://twitter.com/augustben...
Just like the government can require uniforms of its employees, it could require suits when in court
Trickier question for off-duty cops
https://twitter.com/esserzed/status/1266105164517257216">https://twitter.com/esserzed/...
Compared to what we& #39;ve got for police though? Orders of magnitude more accountable https://twitter.com/ramosbugs/status/1266102243855462400">https://twitter.com/ramosbugs...
Agreed
Lots of speed traps magically materialize the last week of the month https://twitter.com/gimblerocket/status/1266100117972623360">https://twitter.com/gimbleroc...
Lots of speed traps magically materialize the last week of the month https://twitter.com/gimblerocket/status/1266100117972623360">https://twitter.com/gimbleroc...
Yep
@TimCushing of TechDirt has several examples here: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160601/07432834592/another-court-says-law-enforcement-officers-dont-really-need-to-know-laws-theyre-enforcing.shtml
(Including">https://www.techdirt.com/articles/... a cite to @ScottGreenfield, who also blogs on this stuff regularly) https://twitter.com/jacobly_/status/1266092741018165250">https://twitter.com/jacobly_/...
@TimCushing of TechDirt has several examples here: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160601/07432834592/another-court-says-law-enforcement-officers-dont-really-need-to-know-laws-theyre-enforcing.shtml
(Including">https://www.techdirt.com/articles/... a cite to @ScottGreenfield, who also blogs on this stuff regularly) https://twitter.com/jacobly_/status/1266092741018165250">https://twitter.com/jacobly_/...
Can& #39;t speak for other states, but in NC "policing for profit" is real
A breakdown of where the money goes is here: https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/741333385415696384
The">https://twitter.com/greg_douc... politicians get more of course, but the police get quite a bit https://twitter.com/genjitsuusagi/status/1266091725459783682">https://twitter.com/genjitsuu...
A breakdown of where the money goes is here: https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/741333385415696384
The">https://twitter.com/greg_douc... politicians get more of course, but the police get quite a bit https://twitter.com/genjitsuusagi/status/1266091725459783682">https://twitter.com/genjitsuu...
Once "soft on crime" became a viable political attack, police became immune from all accountability at every level. They alone are the big
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🍆" title="Aubergine" aria-label="Emoji: Aubergine"> alpha warrior thin blue line commandos separating the savage hordes from white purity and etc etc https://twitter.com/radiophonicpop/status/1266086060477612033">https://twitter.com/radiophon...
Until the police sue you for trademark infringement
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😉" title="Zwinkerndes Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Zwinkerndes Gesicht"> https://twitter.com/shadowcat_mst/status/1266084509109403648">https://twitter.com/shadowcat...
Probably true. But the effects of reform are the same IMO: make policing a service profession instead of a "sheepdog" profession, and things change https://twitter.com/kevinsmayfield/status/1266082809308798977">https://twitter.com/kevinsmay...
The challenge there is that you have a good number of politicians, and at least as many media personalities, whose livelihood hinges on them being slavish apologists for law enforcement https://twitter.com/that_ac/status/1266082695861481473">https://twitter.com/that_ac/s...
I lost it somewhere mid-thread, but insurance companies tend to provide a lot of educational materials as well – because their profits go up if there are fewer claims made
1/ https://twitter.com/caeruleobirb/status/1266079993446137857">https://twitter.com/caeruleob...
1/ https://twitter.com/caeruleobirb/status/1266079993446137857">https://twitter.com/caeruleob...
For example, in the lawyer context, my malpractice insurer provides 2 free all-day classes a year (with food and drinks at a fancy hotel), tons of online resources, lists of best practices, etc etc etc
You& #39;d see police insurers do the same
2/2
@caeruleobirb
You& #39;d see police insurers do the same
2/2
@caeruleobirb
I& #39;ve been fortunate to learn from a lot of folks who came before me and have been working in this space for years
Progress is being made, albeit slowly https://twitter.com/mattbrazy/status/1266079368209711109">https://twitter.com/mattbrazy...
Progress is being made, albeit slowly https://twitter.com/mattbrazy/status/1266079368209711109">https://twitter.com/mattbrazy...
Nah. To the defense bar& #39;s credit, most of us are "always on" looking for holes in a case. You& #39;d need someone with a prosecutorial mindset whose career advancement hinges on convicting dirty cops https://twitter.com/nlongrbreathdin/status/1266073221876584449">https://twitter.com/nlongrbre...
Allegedly :) https://twitter.com/ofnoimport/status/1266068126988267520">https://twitter.com/ofnoimpor...
And this ain& #39;t even all of them Shep!
I totally forgot basic stuff like "everyone has bodycams at all times" and etc https://twitter.com/neolithicsheep/status/1266092638031286274">https://twitter.com/neolithic...
I totally forgot basic stuff like "everyone has bodycams at all times" and etc https://twitter.com/neolithicsheep/status/1266092638031286274">https://twitter.com/neolithic...
Touché – I think it was @AuhsdBond who shared some of the Cali police salary data with me, and the numbers are eye-popping
Probably true in some other well-off states as well, but less so across the southeast and plains https://twitter.com/drlittlejohn137/status/1266132615880310784">https://twitter.com/drlittlej...
Probably true in some other well-off states as well, but less so across the southeast and plains https://twitter.com/drlittlejohn137/status/1266132615880310784">https://twitter.com/drlittlej...
Nah. Trying to thread that needle is too complex a challenge to convey in 30-second ads
I& #39;m not a political guru (cc: @TheRickWilson or @SykesCharlie), but I imagine it would instead take a competing-but-compelling narrative around constitutional rights
https://twitter.com/trustbustinboi/status/1266132306428911617">https://twitter.com/trustbust...
I& #39;m not a political guru (cc: @TheRickWilson or @SykesCharlie), but I imagine it would instead take a competing-but-compelling narrative around constitutional rights
https://twitter.com/trustbustinboi/status/1266132306428911617">https://twitter.com/trustbust...
Speaking anecdotally, one thing I& #39;ve found that works is just the sheer monotony of it
I& #39;ve had friends who became @fsckemall listeners who went from "this never happens" to "Jesus Christ, again???" in the span of a couple years
2/
@trustbustinboi
I& #39;ve had friends who became @fsckemall listeners who went from "this never happens" to "Jesus Christ, again???" in the span of a couple years
2/
@trustbustinboi
It& #39;s also why I support universal bodycams
Risk for unwarranted surveillance is higher, and you end up distributing "trauma porn" when vids get released, but a large chunk of persuadable (mostly white) folks didn& #39;t believe police abuse was common until video
3/
@trustbustinboi
Risk for unwarranted surveillance is higher, and you end up distributing "trauma porn" when vids get released, but a large chunk of persuadable (mostly white) folks didn& #39;t believe police abuse was common until video
3/
@trustbustinboi
Seeing the morbid banality of evil though – several times a month, every month, for years – tends to shock the conscience
4/4
@trustbustinboi
4/4
@trustbustinboi
Less drunk than it takes to think a less-educated police force is a better one https://twitter.com/corvid9teen/status/1266153638403076096">https://twitter.com/corvid9te...
If you got politicians willing to adopt reforms, I think they& #39;d (hopefully) stand up to police unions too
The courts are damn near irretrievable though. You& #39;d need at least 3-4 more hard core defense-friendly justices on SCOTUS to undo bad precedents https://twitter.com/scott_beeson/status/1266154382199910400">https://twitter.com/scott_bee...
The courts are damn near irretrievable though. You& #39;d need at least 3-4 more hard core defense-friendly justices on SCOTUS to undo bad precedents https://twitter.com/scott_beeson/status/1266154382199910400">https://twitter.com/scott_bee...
Of course
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🙄" title="Gesicht mit rollenden Augen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit rollenden Augen"> https://twitter.com/bnonews/status/1266136952874696709">https://twitter.com/bnonews/s...
Ending the §1033 Program would help too, absolutely https://twitter.com/susankey_key/status/1266148078303809543">https://twitter.com/susankey_...
Precisely right https://twitter.com/tuecerprime/status/1266125116800450561">https://twitter.com/tuecerpri...
In terms of need, I& #39;d leave the first two as the first two – but if lower stuff can get enacted sooner, good https://twitter.com/firthermor/status/1266210865168166919">https://twitter.com/firthermo...
Not that I& #39;m aware of, but I may be insufficiently imaginative https://twitter.com/saddratini/status/1266173104834961408">https://twitter.com/saddratin...
I don& #39;t know that this is reformable; they& #39;ll always have 5A rights for something that& #39;s potentially criminal, the question is whether they could be fired for not cooperating https://twitter.com/nc_cyberlaw/status/1266169917008678912">https://twitter.com/nc_cyberl...
At least some of them, yes. There was an extensive LA Times piece not too long ago going through some of the released disciplinary data https://twitter.com/firthermor/status/1266213467121426432">https://twitter.com/firthermo...
Oh absolutely. Extra benefits shouldn& #39;t be enshrined in their contracts, but removing it from their contracts won& #39;t lead to more cooperation
https://twitter.com/bullcityva/status/1266214459481219083">https://twitter.com/bullcityv...
https://twitter.com/bullcityva/status/1266214459481219083">https://twitter.com/bullcityv...
You wondered? It seemed obvious to me. But I& #39;m also cynical https://twitter.com/nc_cyberlaw/status/1266220999437176837">https://twitter.com/nc_cyberl...
There are so many orgs in each state that have been pushing forward, I& #39;m hesitant to start naming them out of fear of leaving out others
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen">
Here in NC, I& #39;m partial to the Southern Coalition for Social Justice ( @scsj) and NAACP ( @ncnaacp), but many more https://twitter.com/ilikebadmusic/status/1266287301786660865">https://twitter.com/ilikebadm...
Here in NC, I& #39;m partial to the Southern Coalition for Social Justice ( @scsj) and NAACP ( @ncnaacp), but many more https://twitter.com/ilikebadmusic/status/1266287301786660865">https://twitter.com/ilikebadm...
Nah. Private prisons should still be abolished anyway as a matter of principle, but they& #39;re only a small piece of the total incarceration problem and generally don& #39;t have an influence on pre-conviction behavior by police https://twitter.com/momsregrettj/status/1266307026319220738">https://twitter.com/momsregre...
I doubt that would ever happen; they couldn& #39;t be forced into doing it, and police unions tend to jealously guard their $$$$ so they can pay it to their leadership
I suspect they& #39;ll get involved trying to get insurance companies to lower rates anyway tho https://twitter.com/ssgcmwatson/status/1266247203590336513">https://twitter.com/ssgcmwats...
I suspect they& #39;ll get involved trying to get insurance companies to lower rates anyway tho https://twitter.com/ssgcmwatson/status/1266247203590336513">https://twitter.com/ssgcmwats...
"Butthead" is tame compared to what I usually get called
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen">
https://twitter.com/catandahalf/status/1266231540482052099">https://twitter.com/catandaha...
https://twitter.com/catandahalf/status/1266231540482052099">https://twitter.com/catandaha...
There are definitely big financial incentives to keeping things exactly as they are
Even in North Carolina – which I& #39;d argue has an above-average court system – it& #39;s intentionally structured to generate a sh*tload of $$$$$ for police and politicians https://twitter.com/larrybrautigam/status/1266344989551931393">https://twitter.com/larrybrau...
Even in North Carolina – which I& #39;d argue has an above-average court system – it& #39;s intentionally structured to generate a sh*tload of $$$$$ for police and politicians https://twitter.com/larrybrautigam/status/1266344989551931393">https://twitter.com/larrybrau...
This is another idea that I& #39;m not sure can legally be done. If I were a run-of-the-mill police officer who hadn& #39;t done anything wrong, I& #39;d argue it& #39;s a due process violation to raid my pension for someone else& #39;s crimes https://twitter.com/i_am_noe1/status/1266346479389741057">https://twitter.com/i_am_noe1...
Not really – if you& #39;ve got enough willing politicians to redirect the money, better to have them reduce it entirely instead
We do have some limited success with fines in NC, which are req& #39;d to go to the local school board... so you see less of them
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen"> https://twitter.com/meganlaser/status/1266347280090779650">https://twitter.com/meganlase...
We do have some limited success with fines in NC, which are req& #39;d to go to the local school board... so you see less of them
Yes, but more hidden
In NC, true civil asset forfeiture at the state level is almost nonexistent: we require convictions first, and the $$ can& #39;t go to the police
So instead, DAs negotiate pleas where seized $$ is "voluntarily" given up to bypass the law https://twitter.com/gimblerocket/status/1266128796127842314">https://twitter.com/gimbleroc...
In NC, true civil asset forfeiture at the state level is almost nonexistent: we require convictions first, and the $$ can& #39;t go to the police
So instead, DAs negotiate pleas where seized $$ is "voluntarily" given up to bypass the law https://twitter.com/gimblerocket/status/1266128796127842314">https://twitter.com/gimbleroc...
(And then of course there& #39;s the "equitable sharing" with the Feds, but that& #39;s a different ball of forfeiture cheese)
@gimblerocket
@gimblerocket
A few tweets up someone inquired about charities doing the work on the ground who could use your financial help
Here are some in Minnesota, from @anamariecox https://twitter.com/anamariecox/status/1266346242604503042">https://twitter.com/anamariec...
Here are some in Minnesota, from @anamariecox https://twitter.com/anamariecox/status/1266346242604503042">https://twitter.com/anamariec...
And several more https://twitter.com/anamariecox/status/1266349818533863428">https://twitter.com/anamariec...
Indeed. Several of them linked in the thread https://twitter.com/mdevalve/status/1266366300063817733">https://twitter.com/mdevalve/...
Probably best to just use one of the @threadreaderapp Unroll links floating around
Try this one: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1266053291684827138.html">https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/12... https://twitter.com/chucklyfun/status/1266364251142336512">https://twitter.com/chucklyfu...
Try this one: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1266053291684827138.html">https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/12... https://twitter.com/chucklyfun/status/1266364251142336512">https://twitter.com/chucklyfu...
If enough judges got skittish about jailing folks, you& #39;d see apocalyptic changes made to the judiciary ASAP
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen"> https://twitter.com/l_t_g_/status/1266369558685736961">https://twitter.com/l_t_g_/st...
Totally agreed, but then you end up back with the issue of sweetheart deals made between city councils and police unions
You& #39;d be amazed the type of stuff that *isn& #39;t* a basis for being fired (including lying, rape, drug addiction, etc) https://twitter.com/max_shields/status/1266378858116218881">https://twitter.com/max_shiel...
You& #39;d be amazed the type of stuff that *isn& #39;t* a basis for being fired (including lying, rape, drug addiction, etc) https://twitter.com/max_shields/status/1266378858116218881">https://twitter.com/max_shiel...
Witty!
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266375204185337857">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266375204185337857">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
Can you imagine the Threadnought in the pre-threading era?
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😂" title="Gesicht mit Freudentränen" aria-label="Emoji: Gesicht mit Freudentränen"> https://twitter.com/danprincellc/status/1266375092486803463">https://twitter.com/danprince...
I keep an auto-updated list here: https://twitter.com/search?q=witty%20from%3Agreg_doucette">https://twitter.com/search... https://twitter.com/cheyinka/status/1266386603813068802">https://twitter.com/cheyinka/...
Absolutely. Private sector unions have different incentives than public sector ones https://twitter.com/patrickgerard01/status/1266387643719471104">https://twitter.com/patrickge...
Of course they don& #39;t. The police will never police themselves.
That& #39;s why external bodies – especially legislatures, historically tasked with both law-making and oversight – have to fix it https://twitter.com/betsymoonchick/status/1266388013589856257">https://twitter.com/betsymoon...
That& #39;s why external bodies – especially legislatures, historically tasked with both law-making and oversight – have to fix it https://twitter.com/betsymoonchick/status/1266388013589856257">https://twitter.com/betsymoon...
There are two angles to any given episode of police brutality: criminal prosecution, and civil lawsuits to compensate victims (under, e.g., 42 USC §1983)
QI only saves police from the civil suits. The buddy-buddy DA-cop friendship stops the prosecutions https://twitter.com/suzwoehrle/status/1266391418215546885">https://twitter.com/suzwoehrl...
QI only saves police from the civil suits. The buddy-buddy DA-cop friendship stops the prosecutions https://twitter.com/suzwoehrle/status/1266391418215546885">https://twitter.com/suzwoehrl...
Can confirm! https://twitter.com/doctorow/status/1266390669951561733">https://twitter.com/doctorow/...
Much obliged, glad it was useful! https://twitter.com/lushultz/status/1266390959920734209">https://twitter.com/lushultz/...
Remember the Qualified Immunity discussion at the start of this thread?
Add another example – today! – to the list
Police forced a man out of his car as he was having a mental health episode, then shot him 15x in the back as he fled b/c "he had a knife" https://twitter.com/bfloodblaw1/status/1266383847140339713">https://twitter.com/bfloodbla...
Add another example – today! – to the list
Police forced a man out of his car as he was having a mental health episode, then shot him 15x in the back as he fled b/c "he had a knife" https://twitter.com/bfloodblaw1/status/1266383847140339713">https://twitter.com/bfloodbla...
The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals decision is here: https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/20/05/191101P.pdf
I& #39;d">https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/20... encourage you to read the dissent
I& #39;d">https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/20... encourage you to read the dissent
Oh don& #39;t sell yourself short, you& #39;re not as witty as a lot of other things too
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266420413250314252">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266420413250314252">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
You have an odd fascination with genitalia. Seek help.
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266421054299389955">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
https://twitter.com/daremstrspoodle/status/1266421054299389955">https://twitter.com/daremstrs...
Agreed. "Police should absolutely *not* carry insurance like everyone else!" is a bizarre hill to die on https://twitter.com/gabrielmobius/status/1266422430098219016">https://twitter.com/gabrielmo...
Yep
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="😔" title="Nachdenkliches Gesicht" aria-label="Emoji: Nachdenkliches Gesicht">
The only other option is to turn and walk away, which ensures there will never be accountability https://twitter.com/blaise137/status/1266427315850002432">https://twitter.com/blaise137...
The only other option is to turn and walk away, which ensures there will never be accountability https://twitter.com/blaise137/status/1266427315850002432">https://twitter.com/blaise137...
I& #39;m not sure this is correct. We have a Law Enforcement Officer Benefit - Retirement Fund that collects $7.50 for every traffic ticket statewide (listed as "LEOB-RF on the cost sheets). Is that under LGERS? https://twitter.com/mvcostanzo/status/1266428264823820288">https://twitter.com/mvcostanz...
Absolutely
But I also realize the odds of it ever changing in my lifetime are scant, and there are more-pressing priorities to address https://twitter.com/the_war_tardis/status/1266432795976650752">https://twitter.com/the_war_t...
But I also realize the odds of it ever changing in my lifetime are scant, and there are more-pressing priorities to address https://twitter.com/the_war_tardis/status/1266432795976650752">https://twitter.com/the_war_t...
A number of city / county-level governments have "Citizen Accountability Boards" (or similar names), but I& #39;m not aware of any of them that have any meaningful oversight or investigative power
We work hard to ignore crimes by police
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🇺🇸" title="Flagge der Vereinigten Staaten" aria-label="Emoji: Flagge der Vereinigten Staaten">
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🦅" title="Adler" aria-label="Emoji: Adler">
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="🇺🇸" title="Flagge der Vereinigten Staaten" aria-label="Emoji: Flagge der Vereinigten Staaten">
https://twitter.com/vulture_8888/status/1266496079245144064">https://twitter.com/vulture_8...
We work hard to ignore crimes by police
https://twitter.com/vulture_8888/status/1266496079245144064">https://twitter.com/vulture_8...
Probably doable for the larger departments in major metro areas. It& #39;d at least be a start
https://twitter.com/taylorgrayson/status/1266836328928481280">https://twitter.com/taylorgra...
https://twitter.com/taylorgrayson/status/1266836328928481280">https://twitter.com/taylorgra...
Holy sh*t https://twitter.com/firthermor/status/1266949211205128192">https://twitter.com/firthermo...
Appreciate the kind words! https://twitter.com/lavignephd/status/1267220514742964231">https://twitter.com/lavigneph...
Glad y& #39;all won, that& #39;s not an easy accomplishment! https://twitter.com/vtgspinster/status/1267235400818573312">https://twitter.com/vtgspinst...